Gooding Christie’s New York Debut Sets a Jaguar D-Type’s Paper Trail Against a Gullwing’s Racing Past - featured image
The 1956 Jaguar D-Type, chassis XKD 552, is offered as Lot 52 with a $6–$7 million estimate. Image via Gooding Christie’s

When Gooding Christie’s opens the first Retromobile New York Auctions at the Javits Center on November 20 and 21, the 160-plus lots will answer a question larger than any single hammer price: what does New York actually pay for? The two cars leading the catalogue suggest two different answers. A 1956 Jaguar D-Type, chassis XKD 552, is being sold on what can be proven. A 1955 Mercedes-Benz 300 SL Alloy Gullwing is being sold on what can be told.

That distinction is the real story of this sale, and it is worth understanding before either estimate is read as a verdict on the market.

The D-Type: a car that kept its tub

Lot 52 carries a $6 million to $7 million estimate, and the case for it rests on structure and paperwork rather than a famous name. The D-Type’s identity lives in its aluminum monocoque, and XKD 552 retains its original tub, its numbered front subframe, its brass data tag and its riveted body tag. Its matching-numbers engine, E2061-9, carries a correctly numbered head and block. Jaguar’s factory records place the car on loan to James Church in July 1956 and back in Jaguar stock that November, before it was sold in 1957 through Lowis and Hodgkiss to John Manussis in Nairobi.

What follows reads like a field guide to how a competition Jaguar was used rather than curated. Manussis, who would later win the 1961 East African Safari outright in a Mercedes-Benz 220 SE, raced it in Kenya. Nolis John Samaras repainted it red with a white stripe and ran it at Nakuru. Roger Lucas, a Montreal jeweler, had it painted gold. Eric Traber of Switzerland sent it to Terry Larson for the restoration that produced its present pale yellow livery, a far cry from its original Battleship Grey. The same owner has held it since 2003, and it has been driven at Goodwood Revival, Le Mans Classic, Monaco, the Monterey Historics and the 1000 Miglia Storica rather than stored.

Serious buyers should read the caveats as carefully as the highlights. The bonnet was replaced in the 1970s, and the tail fin was added during the Larson restoration. The car is titled as a 1955, though it is catalogued as a 1956. None of this is disqualifying. It is the normal biography of a competition car that survived, and the lot essay’s candor about it is precisely what an informed bidder wants.

The Gullwing: provenance with an asterisk

1955 Mercedes-Benz 300 SL Alloy Gullwing in German Racing Silver, raced by Lance Reventlow
The 1955 Mercedes-Benz 300 SL Alloy Gullwing, third of 29 built, is Lot 45 with a $4–$6 million estimate. Image via Gooding Christie’s

Lot 45 is the third of just 29 aluminum-bodied 300 SLs, roughly two percent of Gullwing production, built as a special-order competition option more than 200 pounds lighter than the steel car. Its distinction is who drove it. Mercedes-Benz loaned the car new to Lance Reventlow, the Woolworth heir who would go on to build the Scarab sports racers, and his co-driver Bruce Kessler, both just 19. Together they took an overall win at Torrey Pines in October 1955 with Kessler at the wheel, a class second at Salinas and a third in the SCCA National at Glendale. Original Rudge wheels, the concave-star grille and the luggage set remain with it, and the $4 million to $6 million estimate reflects a car with genuine West Coast racing history from its first weeks of life.

The asterisk is the engine. The lot description states that the original engine was replaced early with another early-1955 date-coded unit, later fitted with an NSL-style camshaft and restamped with the original number, 5500210. The aluminum coachwork has been refinished in German Racing Silver, with a largely patinated red leather interior. Compare that with the black, 45,000-mile alloy car that brought $9.355 million from RM Sotheby’s in 2024 with its original engine, gearbox, body and interior intact, and the gap between the two estimates stops looking like a discount. It is the price of originality. As we noted when examining why the data card decides what a Gullwing is worth, this is where the market draws its line. Gooding itself sold the sixth alloy car in Scottsdale in 2012 for $4.62 million.

What the pairing reveals

Set the two cars side by side and a useful rule emerges. A race record gets a car noticed; matching numbers get it paid for. The Gullwing has the better story and the weaker chain of custody. The D-Type has the more rigorous chain of custody and a thinner competition record. The estimates, $6 million to $7 million against $4 million to $6 million, suggest the market is willing to pay a premium for the provable over the poetic, though not an enormous one. Reventlow’s name still does real work.

It is also a test of geography. Gooding Christie’s has built its reputation on the marquee weekends at Pebble Beach, Amelia Island, Scottsdale and London. Retromobile New York asks whether Christie’s client base in the city will follow a collector-car sale into a convention hall. Two cars carrying a combined $10 million to $13 million of estimates are a serious opening argument. Steve McQueen’s Ferrari 275 GTB/4S NART Spider, announced earlier this autumn, supplies the celebrity. These two supply the substance.

Depth beneath the headliners

The more telling results may sit lower in the catalogue. A 1965 Ferrari 275 GTS in Rosso Cina over beige leather, unseen publicly for more than 40 years, is offered without reserve at $1 million to $1.2 million, which makes it the cleanest read on genuine appetite in the sale. A 1953 Siata 208 CS Berlinetta, one of nine bodied by Carrozzeria Balbo and one of six known survivors, arrives with a 2025 Pebble Beach class win and the Strother MacMinn Most Elegant Sports Car Trophy behind it, at $1.5 million to $2 million. A 1967 Bizzarrini 5300 GT Strada, kept by one Pontiac, Michigan owner for more than 50 years and largely complete and unrestored, is estimated at $500,000 to $800,000. The Mercedes depth is considerable too: a disc-brake, alloy-block 1962 300 SL Roadster in Dunkelblau at $1.8 million to $2.2 million, and a special-order 1957 Gullwing in black over red leather at $1.7 million to $2 million.

Each of these cars is selling a verifiable fact: a long single ownership, a documented survival count, a concours result, a factory color. Collectors rarely pay for rarity in the abstract. They pay for rarity they can confirm.

The Maybach, read correctly

Custom 2027 Mercedes-Maybach S 680 built for LeBron James in light ivory
LeBron James’ custom Mercedes-Maybach S 680 sells to benefit the LeBron James Family Foundation. Image via Mercedes-Benz

The most publicized lot is not a collector-car test at all. The 2027 Mercedes-Maybach S 680, one of two built for LeBron James, who keeps the sister car, is donated by Mercedes to benefit the LeBron James Family Foundation and its I PROMISE program in Akron. It has a 6.0-liter V-12 making 621 horsepower, Mercedes-Benz MANUFAKTUR light ivory paint, Stormy Weather Blue Nappa leather with porcelain stitching, the “LJ” crown on the fenders and headrests, and the coordinates of Akron inscribed on the console. No estimate has been published. As we argued when it was revealed at Pebble Beach, the car is as much about the stage as the sedan. Its result will measure celebrity and philanthropy, and it should be read separately from the D-Type and the Gullwing. As the Foundation’s executive director Michele Campbell put it, the lot is “so much more than an auction to us.”

Why it matters

If the sale price disappeared from this story, the lesson would remain: in 2026 the blue-chip market keeps rewarding cars whose history survives scrutiny. The D-Type and the Gullwing are both important. Only one can show its original engine. How closely New York’s bidders have read that difference, and whether they will pay for it on a November weekend in a convention hall, is what this first Retromobile New York will tell us.

Sources: Gooding Christie’s, Retromobile New York catalogue announcement; Gooding Christie’s, Lot 52, 1956 Jaguar D-Type; Gooding Christie’s, Lot 45, 1955 Mercedes-Benz 300 SL Alloy Gullwing; Gooding Christie’s, LeBron James Mercedes-Maybach S 680 announcement; Gooding Christie’s, Scottsdale 2012 Alloy Gullwing lot archive.

The collector car market, every weekday morning.

Auction results, price moves and what’s crossing the block, read in four minutes. Free, from Modern Car Collector.

No spam, unsubscribe in one click. Or read more about the Brief.

Related Post